46 Comments
User's avatar
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Ralph Ellison’s Invisible Man, Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby, Leslie Silko’s Ceremony, James Welch’s Winter in the Blood, & Vonnegut’s Slaughterhouse Five.

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

What a great list. There are two on there I've never read. I need to get on it!

Expand full comment
Claire Ramsey's avatar

Sheesh. Only five? OK then. Middlemarch (Mary Ann Evans). Into the Beautiful North (Luis Alberto Urrea). La Gatomaquia (Felix Lope de Vega). Just Us. (Claudia Rankine). Any one of the Ramona books (Beverly Cleary).

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

I'm realizing I confined my own list to the 20th century — so hurrah for you for reaching outside the 20th century, and also beyond the US and UK. There are two books on this list I not only have never read, I've never heard of them. Thank you so much, Claire!

Expand full comment
Claire Ramsey's avatar

My pleasure! I have two more that I have got to add so my list equals 7. The Rain God by Arturo Islas. Calling All Heroes by Paco Ignacio Taibo II.

Expand full comment
Claire Ramsey's avatar

Also Leslie Marmon Silko Almanac of the Dead. OK that is my list for now.

Expand full comment
Claire Ramsey's avatar

Which ones haven't you heard of? I know La Gatomaquia is a stretch! But how often do you get an epic poem about battles between armies of cats?

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

Ha! Sounds incredible. I had also never heard of "Into the Beautiful North," though I had heard of Urrea's nonfiction book "The Devil's Highway." Sounds like I need to check out his fiction and poetry.

Expand full comment
Claire Ramsey's avatar

Into the Beautiful North is a Seven Samurai tale. . . word on the internets is that one of the characters from IBN is going to appear in another novel sometime. . . if you read it now you'll be ready!

Expand full comment
Claire Ramsey's avatar

Garden in the Dunes (Silko) is also a really good story. Really. Good.

Expand full comment
Evelyn's avatar

So, I just finished PRIME OF MISS JEAN BRODIE because nobody sells a book like Christopher Frizzelle, and I’m thinking it requires a t-shirt with something like “Romanticism can be fatal.” on the front.

Expand full comment
Evelyn's avatar

It is wickedly funny, but it cuts like a knife. I had seen the movie — and wow! It left an impression — but I’m so glad to have read the book. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Evelyn's avatar

Another t-shirt might be, “Poor Mary Macgregor.” (She doesn’t even get a capital “G”.) Muriel Spark wrote an essay, “Desegregation of Art”, and it/her work is described as “superbly uncuddly”.

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

I spend a bizarre amount of my life thinking about Mary Macgregor -- surprising for such a minor character.

Expand full comment
Evelyn's avatar

THAT is hilarious!

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

She relates directly to what I think that book is really about — what’s going on between the lines…

Expand full comment
Evelyn's avatar

Really!?? What a tease. I was just thinking that I shouldn’t laugh because MM was tragic. The running back and forth both in the upper school science room and then in the hotel was horrible. Her irrational fear or phobia of fire. She was like a mouse in a maze. Yes, and a scapegoat. Even that chipped teacup!!

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

The book has a whole other layer/meaning that the movie lacks. Are you going to be in the club? I can’t wait to get into it. I have so much planned, including a trip though hell with Dante, and some other outside poetry as well. I can’t wait.

Expand full comment
Evelyn's avatar

Hmmm…yes, there is a randomness to a list of top 5…ANNA KARENINA, MIDDLEMARCH, TO THE LIGHTHOUSE (thanks, Christopher!), ONE HUNDRED YEARS OF SOLITUDE, PORTRAIT OF A LADY

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

(my pleasure!)

What exquisite taste you have; great list...

Expand full comment
Evelyn's avatar

Really? I feel like it lacks the variety and breadth of these other lists. I looked at it and realized that I have a “type”. JANE EYRE and THE SECRET GARDEN (my imprint book) could have been on this list. Do you have a first book that marked you or imprinted its DNA on you like SECRET GARDEN did to me? I feel like I see that book in many other books.

Expand full comment
Evelyn's avatar

My question is: where’s MADAME BOVARY? I did not love that novel. On the “Barbie” set, Greta Gerwig had everyone wear a name tag with a movie from the canon on it that they did NOT love. Hers was “Breakfast at Tiffany’s”. We should do that — what well-loved book did not resonate with us? MADAME BOVARY and THE GREAT GATSBY. There! I said it.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth Aquino's avatar

I highly recommend this class/book club, as it was one of my favorite books I’d ever read, too, and I came to it late. Also, “To the Lighthouse” is my favorite book. ❤️

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

Yesssss. 💖

Expand full comment
Peter Trachtenberg's avatar

Invisible Man, Penelope Fitzgerald's The Blue Flower (possibly the greatest historical novel ever written), Orhan Pamuk's Snow, Don DeLillo's Libra, Ishmael Reed's Mumbo Jumbo, though I love the gleeful scatology and universal piss-takery of The Freelance Pallbearers.

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

Thank you for this list, Peter! I remember picking up “Homage to Catalonia” because of you, and now I will be doing the same with several of these titles. What a pleasure getting reading lists from writers and friends.

Expand full comment
Evelyn's avatar

A deep dive of George Orwell is a revelation. I thought DOWN AND OUT IN PARIS AND LONDON was even better!

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

Ooooh, thank you! I just entered the contest.

Expand full comment
Meghan's avatar

Also, current favorite 5: Stephen Fry's The Liar, Bradbury's Dandelion Wine, A Tale of Two Cities, Jane Eyre, and Les Liaisons dangereuses. This list likely to change at any moment.

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

"This list likely to change at any moment" — ha, yes, mine too. Well said.

Ray Bradbury gave a reading at a Borders books when I was a kid, and there were only like 20 people there. He was so cool and nice, and his hair was bright white. He talked about how The New Yorker kept rejecting his short story submissions.

I read "The October Country" after that, a book of his stories, but I don't remember it; I read "Farhenheit 451" in school and loved it; but I don't think I've read "Dandelion Wine." Reading its wikipedia page now — I gotta check this out.

Expand full comment
Evelyn's avatar

I loved DANDELION WINE — required in high school, oddly. And JANE EYRE — formative!!

Expand full comment
Meghan's avatar

Yes! My high school English teacher assigned Dandelion Wine to us but didn't require any work on it. It was a treat for getting through Crime & Punishment!

Expand full comment
Eleanor Anstruther's avatar

Oh yes

Expand full comment
Carmen B's avatar

I feel like a voyeur, returning to the comments on this post to see what books people have added! I will add two, with the caveat that I haven’t re-read either of them recently, and I wonder if they would have the same effect on my heart and soul as they initially did: White Teeth by Zadie Smith and Great Expectations by Charles Dickens.

Expand full comment
Grant Cogswell's avatar

Middlemarch; Half of a Yellow Sun; The Road; Mrs. Dalloway; If He Hollers Let Him Go

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

If He Hollers Let Him Go is new to me. Man, it is so fun asking this question and learning about so many great books! One of these days I want to hear why Dalloway for you is the one; I wouldn't expect it, given the other Woolf books one could choose, books about artists and nature and time and space.

Expand full comment
Grant Cogswell's avatar

IHHLHG is the great LA novel. Sorry Chandler and Didion (in her fiction) don’t touch it Bret Easton Ellis either

Expand full comment
Grant Cogswell's avatar

And just as easy - almost - to swap out: Daniel Deronda, The Book of Ebenezer LePage, Riddley Walker, The Crying of Lot 49, Wuthering Heights

Expand full comment
Christopher Frizzelle's avatar

It may be (can it be?) I have not read any of these.

Expand full comment
Grant Cogswell's avatar

Ok another ten: Madame Bovary, Moby Dick, Invisible Man, The Forsyte Saga, The Great Fire, Anglo-Saxon Attitudes, White Teeth, War and Peace, Gravity’s Rainbow, Battles in the Desert

Expand full comment
Grant Cogswell's avatar

What the hell a round 30: Ulysses, To the Lighthouse, As I Lay Dying, No Country for Old Men, The Alexandria Quartet, Jane Eyre, I, Claudius, The Long Night of White Chickens, The Mill on the Floss, Little Women

Expand full comment
Claire Ramsey's avatar

OMG I forgot all about The Long Night of White Chickens. I'm mortified that I forgot it b/c I read it twice. . . I like your lists Grant.

Expand full comment
Grant Cogswell's avatar

You’re stoked strap in

Expand full comment